Tuesday, October 2, 2012

Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton

Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton were two great visionaries; they had both had ideas that would change America into what it is today. Although they were both visionaries, they both had very different visions of what America could be. Jefferson was a strong proponent of the Bill of Rights; he supported agriculture and a strong state government. Hamilton wanted a large federal government, akin to the British Monarchy. He believed that industry and trading were the keys to the nation’s success. Jefferson wanted a quite agricultural collection of states; Hamilton wanted an industrial power house of a nation that would dominate the world market. Fast Forward 200 years and we see a combination of these juxtaposed positions. America’s strong government has been a main player in foreign trading and politics. Its people as a whole though embody more of a Jefferson approach, they support human rights, farming and reduced foreign dependency. The American government embodies Hamiltonian ideals whilst the people are pro Jefferson. This duality creates an interesting dynamic that gives America the ability to eat its cake and have it too. On one side its strong Hamilton influenced government can drill deep for oil into the Gulf of Mexico, start wars overseas and set up prisons on a communist countries soil. The American people rally against this government – the occupy Wall Street movement, protests against federal spending and human rights abuses. Jefferson and Hamilton clashed on many ideas about what the country could be, and today the Government and the People clash about what the country has become.

3 comments:

  1. Hey Gabe,
    I really enjoyed this post. The idea that America has become a mix of these two visionary's ideas of a nation is something I found really interesting. You seem to know a lot about the topic so I would be curious to hear whether you think aspect of duality was the best course of action for our nation, or if there is an advantage in singling in on a single ideal/vision?
    Thanks,
    John

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. In my opinion, America will always have a sense of duality, whether it be north vs south, democrat vs republican, pro life vs pro abortion. America is a country that thrives off of differences in opinion, sometimes it can spark hate and anger between different groups, but always it highlights that we are not all the same and everyone's opinion is a valid one. Having one view is like not having genetic diversity, you will never learn from your peers if your peers think exactly what you think, and you will never evolve if each person is an exact clone of everyone else. In order for America as a whole to move forward, we need not unite under one common belief, but respectfully share our differences in opinion and debate about the best way to come to a middle ground.

      Delete
  2. Hi Gabe,
    I really enjoyed how you compared and contrasted these two figures in American History. It is funny how now the government/America is almost like a combination of the two leaders. It is amazing to believe that their decisions then are still effecting American today. What leader out of Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson do you think had the best ideas for the country?
    Thanks!
    Sierra

    ReplyDelete